The Delhi High Court has raised concerns that Instagram’s Remix tool could facilitate copyright infringement and the misuse of personal identities.
Meta Platforms’ Instagram Remix feature has come under judicial scrutiny in India over concerns that tools allowing users to modify and republish others’ videos could facilitate copyright infringement and the misuse of personal identities.
During a hearing last week in a lawsuit brought by educator Vikas Divyakirti, Delhi High Court Judge Anup Jairam Bhambhani reportedly described the feature as a “mischievous” tool that could enable content manipulation and copyright infringement. Divyakirti alleges that his lectures, identity and likeness were misused through manipulated videos, fake profiles and unauthorized endorsements. Meta’s lawyer said the company would examine the court’s concerns.
The case raises a broader question about whether social-media companies could face greater legal responsibility not only for hosting infringing or AI-manipulated content but also for designing tools that make such misuse easier.
Divyakirti, founder of coaching institute Drishti IAS, is seeking protection against the alleged misuse of his identity and copyrighted content. His lawyers claim that fake social-media profiles, manipulated recordings of his lectures, deepfakes and unauthorized endorsements have been used to misrepresent him.
The dispute could extend beyond conventional copyright enforcement, raising questions about whether existing intermediary protections adequately address risks created by platforms’ own content-editing and AI tools, intellectual property lawyers told MLex.
The Indian scrutiny follows a separate controversy in the US, where Meta withdrew an Instagram-linked feature associated with its Muse Image AI model in July. The feature allowed users to reference eligible public Instagram accounts when generating AI images, prompting criticism from entertainment-industry representatives, including SAG-AFTRA and Creative Artists Agency, over consent and the potential unauthorized use of creators’ images, likenesses and intellectual property. Meta removed the functionality within days, acknowledging that it had “missed the mark.”
Although the withdrawn Muse feature is distinct from Instagram Remix, both controversies raise questions about the responsibility platforms bear when their own tools make it easier to transform content created by others.
The Indian proceedings could have wider implications for social-media and AI companies if courts begin examining the design of content-creation tools alongside platforms’ responses to unlawful uploads. Such scrutiny could increase pressure on platforms to strengthen creator controls, consent mechanisms, attribution and safeguards against manipulation while preserving legitimate uses such as commentary, criticism and transformative content.
The court’s observations, however, were preliminary and do not establish that Remix itself infringes copyright or that Meta has a new legal duty to redesign the feature or monitor all content created using it.
For Meta, the immediate risk is greater judicial scrutiny of whether its own product features facilitate the copyright and identity abuses that its enforcement systems are intended to prevent. The case also raises a potentially significant question for AI developers and social-media platforms: whether legal scrutiny should extend beyond what users upload to the tools platforms provide to help them create it.
*banned and designated as extremist in Russia
Source: MLex