Russian Legal Order and the Legal Order of the Eurasian Economic Union: An Uneasy Relationship

25.09.2017 233
Back to Publications
Article

Russian Legal Order and the Legal Order of the Eurasian Economic Union: An Uneasy Relationship

Russian Law Journal. 2017. Vol. 5. No. 2. P. 33-52.

Karliuk M.

Eurasian integration has created a new legal order – the so-called “Union law” of the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU). This legal order has its own narrative, principles, hierarchy of rules, and innovations such as the direct applicability of decisions of its regulatory body. Russian legal order is generally accommodating towards international law, which is equally applicable to Union law. However, the recent practice of the Russian Constitutional Court has claimed that Russia can set aside international obligations based on national constitution, which indirectly targets the viability of the EAEU legal order. This is further complicated by the Eurasian judiciary, which, as the main interpretative authority within the integration, has tried to take on an activist role, somewhat borrowing approaches from the European Union. In its turn, the Russian Constitutional Court has voiced its differences in certain approaches. This variability of practices and approaches clearly undermines the “unity” of the EAEU legal order and the interweaving of national and regional legal frameworks. This article analyses the relationship of the two legal orders to assess the possibilities for tensions between them. It points out the sources of such tensions, which lie in certain indeterminacies within the EAEU legal order, temptations to assert power, and recent far-reaching practices of the Russian Constitutional Court.


Full publication

Related content

25.09.2017 Article
The Eurasian Economic Union: An EU-Inspired Legal Order and Its Limits
The article argues that the EAEU lags behind the EU both in terms of the autonomy of its legal order and in its ability to ensure the effective functioning of the organization. The EAEU’s supranational features are limited, as it relies predominantly on intergovernmental elements with a view to preserving the interests of all of its member states.
Karliuk M.
Review of Central and East European Law. 2017. No. 42. P. 50-72.
15.03.2017 Article
The Limits of the Judiciary within the Eurasian Integration Process
This article looks into the ability of the Court of the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU) to ensure the functioning of the EAEU legal order. It is argued that it will be a hard task for the EAEU Court to ensure the uniform application of EAEU law. This follows from the removal of the preliminary ruling procedure, which has left the Court without a powerful vehicle of interpretation of law and has isolated it from national courts.
Karliuk M.
The European Union and the Eurasian Economic Union: Moving toward a Greater Understanding. Amsterdam; The Hague: Eleven International Publishing, 2016.
13.12.2016 Article
The limits of the judiciary within the Eurasian integration process
This article looks into the ability of the Court of the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU) to ensure the functioning of the EAEU legal order. It is argued that it will be a hard task for the EAEU Court to ensure the uniform application of EAEU law.
Karliuk M.
Law. LAW. Высшая школа экономики, 2016. No. 69.
24.09.2015 Article
The Eurasian Economic Union: An EU-Like Legal Order in the Post-Soviet Space? Law. LAW. Высшая школа экономики, 2015. No. WP BRP 53/LAW/2015. Karliuk M.
​В статье анализируются данные особенности с целью определения, позволяют ли правовые изменения, сопровождающие создание нового образования, обеспечить эффективное функционирование ЕАЭС и является ли данный правопорядок автономным подобно ЕС.
Karliuk M.
Law. LAW. Высшая школа экономики, 2015. No. WP BRP 53/LAW/2015.